Tasting a self-selected WhistlePig Rye Whiskey Comparisons lineup consisting of their Straight 10yr vs. 15yr and Farmstock Rye Crop No. 002 & No. 003

A quick getaway

I’ve lived in New England for over five years now and have visited every state in the Northeast except for Vermont. It’s not for lack of desire…I travelled to Vermont when I was fifteen (that was ** mumble, mumble ** years ago), and I’ve wanted to go back ever since. And it’s not because we haven’t travelled about…my husband and I try to have as many “adventures” in New England as possible. It’s just that most of our trips have been day trips, and since Vermont is just that much farther away from Boston, I had thought we couldn’t get there and back in a day. So when we decided to spend the night in Vermont, I was really excited. We hit this baker’s highlights of King Arthur Flour in Norwich and Ben & Jerry’s in Waterbury along the way to our cute little B&B, The Inn at Round Barn Farm, in Waitsfield. I was also excited to stop at Vermont’s own WhistlePig Rye Whiskey Distillery for a tasting (a highlight for any rye whiskey drinker).

Getting underway

WhistlePig Rye Whiskey, started with the help of the late Master Distiller Dave Pickerell, based their products on a stock of found 10-year-old blended Canadian Whiskey. Since then their lineup has grown from that initial 10yr Straight Rye Whiskey by experimenting with different cask finishes and blends. Now WhistlePig is moving towards their 100% “Triple Terroir” philosophy, i.e. whiskey distilled from locally grown grain, proofed with water from the farm, and aged in casks made from their Estate-grown Vermont White Oak. Called their Farmstock Rye Crop, the plan is to continually increase the percentage of their homemade whiskey in the expressions and reduce the need for other outside blends.


WhistlePig Tasting Room Views
Views from WhistlePigs’ Tasting Room


Unfortunately, the distillery itself isn’t open to the public, but there is a lovely tasting room in Waterbury (just down the road from Ben & Jerry’s) with free tastings where you can choose four samples from the six they had on offer (there was a small charge for a sample of their premium whiskeys). I decided on a comparison lineup showing the difference in Straight Rye Whiskey’s aging and the difference in the Farmstock’s blends. Josh Thomas, our guide in the tasting room, gave a wealth of information about each pour, and the room was comfortable and nicely appointed with WhistlePig products.

Let’s get to it, then!


WhistlePig Rye Whiskys lineup
My self-selected WhistlePig Rye Whisky lineup

WhistlePig Rye Whiskey Comparisons

At the WhistlePig Rye Tasting Room, July 21, 2019

WhistlePig 10yr

50%ABV, Canadian whiskey aged in New American Oak with a bourbon barrel finish
Course: Drinks
Cuisine: American
Keyword: American Whiskey, Blended Whiskey, Bourbon Cask Finish, Rye Whiskey, Whiskey

Tasting Notes

  • Nose: corn, oatmeal, clover honey, ferns, light caraway
  • Taste: immediate rye, oatmeal, white pepper, corn sugar
  • Finish: fades slowly to caraway, honey, brown sugar
  • Comments: sweet and spicy, not aggressive, flavorful

WhistlePig 15yr

46%ABV, Straight Rye 10 yr, aged an additional 5 yrs in Estate Vermont Oak
Course: Drinks
Cuisine: American
Keyword: American Whiskey, Blended Whiskey, Bourbon Cask Finish, Rye Whiskey, Whiskey, White Oak Cask Finish

Tasting Notes

  • Nose: soft caraway, sweet green peas, clover honey, leathery
  • Taste: soft entry, allspice and white pepper rises, leather in the background
  • Finish: lingers on the spicy allspice, then fades to soft rye, dill pickles
  • Comments: gentled from the 10yr, more leather and green notes

WhistlePig Rye Straight 10yr, WhistlePig Rye Straight 15yr


WhistlePig Farmstock Rye Crop No. 002

43%ABV, blended with 32% 2yr whiskey, made from the WhistlePig farm's rye, water, and wood, 46% 6yr MGP Rye, and 23% 10yr Canadian whiskey
Course: Drinks
Cuisine: American
Keyword: American Whiskey, Blended Whiskey, Rye Whiskey, Whiskey

Tasting Notes

  • Nose: hay, leather, musty, library bookshelves
  • Taste: cinnamon, quickly turns to caraway, dust
  • Finish: lingers long with rye spice and dust
  • Comments: really interesting balance between rye whisky and aged bourbon flavors, not a strong rye

WhistlePig Farmstock Rye Crop No. 003

43%ABV, majorityof the blend (51%) is from the Triple Terroir whiskey
Course: Drinks
Cuisine: American
Keyword: American Whiskey, Blended Whiskey, Rye Whiskey, Whiskey

Tasting Notes

  • Nose: lemongrass, granola, cedar wood
  • Taste: soft hay to start, caraway and green grass rises with white pepper, falls, then allspice rises
  • Finish: lingers on the caraway and allspice
  • Comments: really a lot happening, a sine wave of flavors that rise and fall

WhistlePig Rye Farmstock Crop Whiskeys

Destination Reached

WhistlePig Rye Whiskey continues to impress me every time I try it…from the original WhistlePig 10 yr to Gordon’s WhistlePig Single Barrel Rye Select 10 yr. Being able to select my own WhistlePig Rye Whiskey comparisons, in its home state, added to the fun this trip held for me (to my final New England state, no less). Hopefully the next time I make it up to Vermont, the distillery itself will be ready for touring. After all…Vermont is calling!

Slainté! L’chaim! Cheers!


(Visited 53 times, 1 visits today)

1 Comment

  1. Pingback: Vermont calling, Pt. 2: Smugglers’ Notch Distillery whiskey - Scotch & Scones

Leave A Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.